So I’m sure you’ve heard about the hot new controversy that is sweeping the nation. The one where a 49ers quarterback decides to protest by sitting down during the national anthem. And before I talk about what I want to talk about regarding this “controversy” I’d like to make it clear what my opinion on it is.
I don’t care.
I really, really, really don’t care. Like, on a scale of 1 to 10, it’s a 0. I don’t care. This is exactly the bullshit kind of “controversy” I talked about in a previous post and I was over it before it was even real news. He’s a football player, he’s protesting about something he cares about, let him do it, who fucking cares. Honestly. You don’t need to interview experts or other athletes or bring it up to politicians. It’s not news. It’s not a story.
The best thing I saw on it was “Colin Kaepernick is a rich quarterback, why should he be protesting anything? Because if he was Colin Kaepernick, employee at Verizon Wireless nobody would give a shit.” Which is exactly true. The only reason anybody cares is because it’s a sports guy doing a thing. If the guy next to you at the football game doesn’t get up during the national anthem, do you get in his face about not being a patriot? Do you go bare-knuckle brawling in the aisle? Is your experience ruined if the guy in seat 42B across the way didn’t get up? Are you going to walk over there and give that person a piece of your mind?
It’s manufactured controversy. It’s dumb. I don’t care.
BUT.
I do care about psychology, because I majored in it. And what I really find interesting about it is the cognitive dissonance that is on display during people’s reactions to it. I’ve seen things like pictures of people holding an American flag standing on Colin Kaepernick’s jersey to prove a point. What point? That apparently this quarterback jerk is disrespectful to the flag, to the country, to all the soldiers who have died to make America free, etc. etc. A big argument I’ve also seen is the “well, I understand he’s expressing his First Amendment right, but I’m going to express my First Amendment right and call him an asshole.” And that’s understandable and perfectly fine because, you know, First Amendment rights and all that.
But let me tell you something. There’s this guy who’s been on TV for over a year now who has been saying America sucks every chance he gets. He’s been belligerent, insulting, misogynistic, and racist. He’s been exercising his First Amendment right to be an asshole (and call people assholes) all over the place. If you missed my thinly veiled reference, I’ll immediately clarify: I’m talking about Donald Trump.
If you disagree with me, don’t forget his campaign slogan is “Make America Great Again.” He is directly implying that America as it stands is not great. That it needs fixing. Which I’m pretty sure is the reasoning behind Colin Kaapernick’s sit-down protest. He thinks there are things in America that need fixing.
And yet there are people who in one breath say they want to make Donald Trump president, but in the very next breath say that Colin Kaepernick is a spoiled brat and an idiot. One is “speaking his mind” and “telling it like he sees it” but the other is “trying to gain attention” and “a daft prima donna.”
So what’s the difference between the two situations?
(Some of you are going to say Trump is white and Kaepernick is black, and while yes, that is a big difference and in all likelihood a huge factor, that’s not what I’ll be delving into here.)
The difference is simple.
Colin Kaepernick “disrespected” the flag. He “disrespected” the national anthem.
And for the love of God, people love their symbols.
I’m not knocking it. It’s so much easier to get outraged when an object is attacked over an idea. Plus, you get emotionally invested in those symbols. Somebody loses their wedding ring down the shower drain and they go nuts, but it doesn’t mean the marriage is over. But there’s an attachment there. It’s why people give a shit if you burn the American flag. Or a book. Or a bra. It’s a symbol of something.
Donald Trump talks in vague ideas. He wants to “build a wall” but skips around how he’s going to actually get it done. Similarly, his disrespect is vague. He wants to make America great again, but he never crosses the line to actual disrespect of the country itself by attacking a specific symbol (other than the President, I mean HA! It’s not like the President is the leader of the country and a huge symbolic presence in the world at large, right? Right guys?).
Patriotism is directly tied to symbolism. Americans stand behind our flag as a symbol. We stand behind our soldiers as a symbol. Just being in the military demands respect because we put high value on serving the country. But we don’t respect other flags as much. Would you hold the same outrage if Kaepernick didn’t stand during the Canadian national anthem? Do you think Canadians would have the same outrage if a Canadian athlete didn’t stand? And religion is tied to symbols, too. A Christian is probably going to directly oppose burning a Bible more than they will burning a Quran. Catholics might not care if a Book of Mormon gets torn to shreds, but a member of the LDS church would. Some of the most powerful beliefs are tied to the symbolism. A right-side up cross is holy, an upside-down cross is Satanic.
And Colin Kaepernick’s act of sitting down is two symbols clashing. It’s America’s patriotism clashing with America’s love of sports. We idolize our athletes. We wear jerseys of our favorite teams. We have pennants and jackets and helmets. We’ve turned them into symbols. It’s why we’re heartbroken when a respected athlete turns out to have been doping, or gets into a domestic violence dispute, or is Tim Tebow.
And that’s where this cognitive dissonance comes into play. Politicians we don’t respect. So Trump can say whatever he wants because he’s SUPPOSED to say America sucks. He’s SUPPOSED to insult the President and his rival, because we’re a two-party system and Republicans are better than Democrats, obviously. He’s going to fix everything!
But sports stars are our symbols. And we can’t have our symbols disappoint us. So we get outraged that one symbol isn’t respecting another symbol.
I’m using the royal we here. As I’ve said before, I don’t care. I don’t put my faith in symbols. But it sure is fascinating to watch others react.
I don’t really have an ending to this. This was a spur of the moment post. All I had was a slight rant prepared, and I don’t really have a rug to tie the room together. So I guess I’ll just end with a link to a psychology piece on the social function of symbols in case people feel like reading about it a little more.
And for the love of all that is holy, be happy! Don’t let media (social or otherwise) dictate what you should feel outraged about, or that you should feel outraged at all! Focus on happiness! CBS cares!